For once, I listened to the show live, but was unable to call in. A few ideas:
THE KING OF KONG - made to look like Donkey Kong, only you're running around in Billy Mitchell's hot sauce warehouse, avoiding hot sauces that Billy throws at you, and Billy's goons. There's a time limit, and if you don't make progress fast enough the old referee guy shows up and berates you (lose one life). You obviously play the other Guy, the challenger.
ROCKY BALBOA - for Wii; giving life to that awesome video game simulation that got people talking!
CONTROL - not as a stand-alone game but as a ROCK BAND expansion! Only Joy Division songs. On further levels, you get distracted by beautiful Belgian fanzine writers, boring housewives, and suicide.
FIGHT CLUB - split up as part round-based strategy game (for Project Mayhem), and fight game. Lots of multiplayer options, possibly a full-out MMORPG. (Might be an even better game once FIGHT CLUB: THE MUSICAL opens.)