Jouster pointed out that the Gargoyla call available on MP3 wasn't listed in the Newbridgctionary. So I did a ridiculous amount of digging and found that Gargoyla's "last post" on the old, old board indicates that this call was from:
March 18, 2003: Gargoyla Gets Banned (), The Chippert Report () – No Archive
Oh, the wonders of completism. Jouster also let me know the actual dates of Rock, Rot and Rule and Conventions, Inc., which are now updated on the webpage.
If anybody has a complete recording of Conventions, Inc. (without the interruption from the time it was rebroadcast), that would be a cool thing to have.
buffcoat!