I'm trying to figure out what episode this was in... I don't remember who the caller was or the exact premise, but the basic idea was that Tom and the caller were talking about how they used to be in a band together.. or at least they had played music together or something, and talked about a lot of specific stuff from their past.
Then halfway through the caller claims that he thought he was talking to someone else. Tom proceeds to go through all the specific stuff they talked about and the caller claims that all the same stuff happened with this other guy too.
If I remember correctly there's also a call with Philly Boy Roy (or maybe Bryce? I don't remember) where he falls down the stairs or something.
This was the first episode I ever listened to. At the time I had just heard the show was funny but didn't really know the deal, so I just assumed the calls were all real. For me it was the perfect introduction because the whole first half of that call was totally believable and then they flip it around and take it to ridiculous lengths. It was great being so invested in the call as a real call and then hearing it take that turn and just keep going.
I'm trying to turn some friends on to the show and I'd love to point them to that episode (among others).
Any help is appreciated.