I listen to:
The Moth Podcast
NPR: All Songs Considered
NPR: Live Concerts from All Songs Considered
This American Life
WFMU's Best Show Gems with Tom Scharpling
WFMU's The Best Show on WFMU with Tom Scharpling
And also to Word Balloon episodes with Matt Fraction, Ed Brubaker, Brian Michael Bendis, and some other random episodes I think sound interesting.
EDITED TO ADD: And I will be sure to check out Am I Right?? sometime soon.